The Universal Declaration of Material Rights Forums Suggestion Box In what way can materials have rights?

  • Author
    Posts
  • Ruud Wagenaar
    Post count: 0

    For my master philosophy I wrote an essay about the ‘materials matters’ concept of Thomas Rau. My rate was ‘FAILED’ because I automatically assumed that it’s possible to give materials ‘rights’ but unfortunately this is not the case according my professor. Only living organism can have rights because the object to give or allocate rights to must have consciousness and dignity. It should be possible to subject to pain, torture, slavery or other negative subjections in order to allocate rights to it. I did not realise that this was a mishap in the thinking of my essay as I considered it as a leverage, a supporting token, say an emphasis to have respect for materials, to make people aware that materials are of precious substance for us and our offspring, the people who come after us when we are dead. To claim that materials have rights is hence nonsense according philosophy and law. But I still think that Rau’s vision is brilliant, because we should take care for materials in order to support and take care for our next generations and we should do everything possible in order to recycle them hence not to destroy them.

  • Turntoo
    Member
    Post count: 1

    Dear Ruud, thank you so much for your comment. In fact I believe it is a classic example of a professor not being able to grasp a new emerging reality. As in fact we presented the UDMR at the Carnegie Peace Building Dialogues at the Peace Palace in The Hague today. The host of the session was Jan Peter Balkenende, other prominent speakers were Rabbij Abraham Soetendorp and Ezekiel Ole Katato leader of the Massai. The session was moderated by Nina dos Santos from CNN. They all agreed, that a Universal Declaration of Material Rights would make perfect sense. There will be a video from the session online shortly. Keep exploring new concepts in you studies! Best, Sabine

Reply To: In what way can materials have rights?
Your information: